Is theguardian.com a reliable source?

Written by NewsWall Editorial Team · Last updated:

Is theguardian.com reliable?

Assessing the journalistic quality and credibility of a leading news source


Introduction

For anyone navigating the digital news landscape, reliability is a top concern. Among global outlets, theguardian.com (The Guardian) is recognized as a major source of English-language journalism with a wide international readership. With diverse opinions circulating online—both positive and critical—is theguardian.com reliable? As misinformation and polarized reporting challenge reader trust everywhere, understanding how The Guardian is rated for reliability has become increasingly relevant.

This article takes an evidence-based look at theguardian.com’s journalistic quality, transparency, and reputation. Drawing on independent research, industry watchdogs, and the comprehensive NewsWall rating system, we aim to address the question: can readers trust what they see on The Guardian’s digital pages?

First, here is how NewsWall currently grades theguardian.com for reliability and trustworthiness:

Grade Score
very good A+ > 89
A 89 - 84
A- 83 - 79
good B+ 78 - 74
B 73 - 67
B- 66 - 62
satisfactory C+ 61 - 56
C 55 - 49
C- 48 - 44
sufficient D+ 43 - 39
D 38 - 32
poor D- 31 - 26
insufficient F < 26
theguardian.com scores a total of 69 Plus Points and 38 Minus Points in our evaluation of journalistic quality.
This corresponds to a score of 63* resp. the grade B- (good).
*: (69 + 5 BP) * 100 / (69 + 5 BP + 38 + 5 BP)


Background: The Guardian’s Role in Global News

What is theguardian.com?

The Guardian’s online presence, theguardian.com, provides digital access to the content of The Guardian and its sister title, The Observer. The Guardian was originally founded in Manchester in 1821. Today, theguardian.com serves as the digital platform for these newspapers, offering breaking news, analysis, commentary, and investigative journalism to a global readership.

  • Ownership: The Guardian is owned by the Scott Trust, which is designed to safeguard editorial independence and reinvest profits into journalism rather than distributing them to shareholders.
  • Editorial scope: The Guardian covers international, national, and local news, with sections including politics, science, business, culture, and more.
  • Audience: The Guardian reports over a million paying digital supporters and a global reach, including readers in the UK, US, and Australia.

The Need for Reliable News

With information overload and viral misinformation prevalent in digital spaces, assessing the reliability of any news source remains important. Audiences often depend on trustworthy outlets to hold power to account, uncover stories in the public interest, and distinguish fact from opinion or propaganda. In this context, The Guardian’s reputation as a source of fact-based reporting continues to be subject to scrutiny and public discussion.


Criteria for Assessing the Reliability of theguardian.com

Evaluating whether a news site like theguardian.com is reliable involves using clear, evidence-based criteria. At NewsWall, we use a methodology that combines independent watchdog reports, industry awards, transparency indicators, and fact-checker records. Key assessment categories include:

1. Journalistic Quality and Industry Recognition

  • Awards and accolades: Recognition by major journalism awards (such as the Pulitzer Prize and British Journalism Awards) is commonly viewed as an indicator of journalistic excellence.
  • Peer reputation: Endorsements or citations from press councils, journalism associations, and expert panels may provide further context about reputation.

2. Editorial Standards and Corrections

  • Transparency: Does the outlet have a published code of editorial standards? Does it routinely publish corrections and clarifications?
  • Accountability: Is there a publicly available process for readers to report errors or submit complaints?

3. Independence and Ownership

  • Funding and ownership model: Does the business structure aim to encourage editorial freedom or reduce conflicts of interest?
  • Separation from political or commercial pressure: Is there evidence that reporting practices are structured to limit undue influence?

4. Reliability Ratings by Watchdog Organizations

  • Media Bias/Fact Check (MBFC): Rates outlets for both factual reporting and bias.
  • Ad Fontes Media: Publishes data-driven reliability and bias scores using a panel methodology.
  • Fact-checking record: Reviews from reputable fact-checking organizations (such as Full Fact, PolitiFact, and IFCN signatories) regarding the outlet’s reporting accuracy.

5. Audience Trust and Reputation

  • Reader trust surveys: Independent polls may indicate how readers and the public rate an outlet’s trustworthiness.
  • Membership and supporter numbers: The size of the outlet’s base of paying supporters may reflect levels of public trust.

NewsWall’s Method for Grading theguardian.com

NewsWall applies a point-based system that weighs “plus points” for evidence of quality (such as awards, transparency, and trust) against “minus points” for evidence of concerns (such as failed fact checks or unresolved controversies). Each item is sourced and documented. This produces a numerical score, which is then translated into a letter grade for easy comparison:

  • B- (good)

Details of this calculation and the sources behind each point are available below.


In the following sections, we will apply these criteria to theguardian.com, reviewing both the evidence for high reliability and the criticisms raised by independent monitors. This approach is intended to provide a balanced and authoritative answer to the question: Is theguardian.com reliable?

Evidence and Analysis: Is theguardian.com Reliable?


Ownership and Funding Model

A key factor in assessing theguardian.com’s reliability is its ownership structure. The Guardian is owned by the Scott Trust, which is designed to ensure the editorial and financial independence of The Guardian and its journalism. The Scott Trust is not accountable to profit-seeking shareholders, and according to published statements, any financial surplus is reinvested in journalism.

  • Scott Trust’s mission: “to secure the financial and editorial independence of the Guardian in perpetuity” (source).
  • No dividends or private owners: All profits are retained to fund news coverage and innovation, according to The Guardian’s disclosures.
  • Global footprint: This structure is cited by independent experts as supporting in-depth coverage without the same reliance on paywalls or corporate advertising as seen at some other outlets.

This model is referenced by several independent observers as supporting editorial integrity, enabling The Guardian to focus on public interest journalism.


Press Council and Editorial Accountability

Editorial accountability remains essential to trust in any news organization. The Guardian publishes an Editorial Code of Practice (source), maintains public corrections columns, and offers a formal complaints process (source).

  • Corrections and clarifications: The Guardian regularly publishes corrections and clarifications, making visible any factual errors or omissions identified in its reporting.
  • Complaints mechanism: Readers can submit corrections and complaints through online channels, which are reviewed by a dedicated Readers’ Editor or editorial review panel.

According to available sources, The Guardian is not regulated by the UK’s Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) at the time of this review, but maintains internal standards referencing industry best practices and similar codes.


Third-Party Ratings: Fact-Checkers, Bias & Reliability

Media Bias/Fact Check (MBFC)

  • Bias: Rated as “Center-Left” in political orientation by MBFC.
  • Factual reporting: Assigned a “Mixed” factual reporting score by MBFC, with this rating explained as a result of occasional overstatements or errors that have been noted and addressed in coverage.

(MBFC source)

Ad Fontes Media

  • Reliability: Placed in the “Middle” band of reliability by Ad Fontes Media, indicating most reporting is grounded in fact and opinion pieces are labeled.
  • Bias: Rated as having a slight left-of-center bias, consistent with some other UK broadsheet media.

(Ad Fontes Media source)

Fact-Checking Organizations

  • Full Fact, PolitiFact, and other International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN) signatories have reviewed Guardian reporting on multiple occasions.
    • Some articles have required corrections, often when covering complex statistics or third-party research.
    • The Guardian has published corrections to errors brought to its attention (Full Fact examples).

Industry Awards and Peer Recognition

  • Pulitzer Prize: The Guardian US received the Pulitzer Prize for Public Service (2014) for reporting on NSA surveillance revelations with The Washington Post (Pulitzer citation).
  • British Journalism Awards: The Guardian and Observer have been recognized in the British Journalism Awards, including for investigative journalism, technology journalism, and sports reporting (Press Gazette).

These recognitions are widely cited as indicators of theguardian.com's ongoing commitment to journalistic quality.


Content Sample Analysis

A review of theguardian.com at the time of writing finds:

  • News, not opinion, is prominent on the homepage: Reports are typically labeled by type (“news,” “analysis,” “opinion”).
  • Sources cited: Articles frequently cite official documents, direct sources, and statements from named individuals or organizations.
  • Corrections visible: Corrections and clarifications are visible both on individual articles and through the dedicated corrections page.
  • Range of coverage: The Guardian covers global topics alongside local stories, including sections on politics, science, culture, climate, and more.

Audience and Reach

  • International presence: The Guardian provides digital editions for UK, US, Australia, and international readers.
  • Supporter base: The Guardian reports having over 1 million recurring digital supporters (Press Gazette).
  • Trusted brand: Surveys such as the Reuters Institute Digital News Report have ranked The Guardian among the UK’s most trusted news brands among its regular readers (Reuters DNR).

Final Verdict: Is theguardian.com Reliable?

Based on the Scott Trust ownership model, editorial standards, third-party ratings, fact-checker records, industry awards, and a global audience, theguardian.com demonstrates key hallmarks of journalistic reliability. The NewsWall grade (B- – good) reflects a balanced assessment of strengths and weaknesses:

  • The Guardian’s Scott Trust model is cited as supporting editorial independence and public-interest reporting.
  • Recognized for transparency, with visible corrections and published editorial standards.
  • Occasional errors and overstatements have occurred, but these are generally acknowledged and addressed.
  • The Guardian has received industry awards for investigative reporting and has been recognized by peers.
  • Third-party monitors have rated The Guardian as center-left in orientation and “mixed” on factuality, reflecting a blend of news, features, and commentary.

Summary: While no news organization is free from error, our review finds that theguardian.com meets a high standard for reliability among major international media. Readers are encouraged to use multiple reputable sources and to consult available corrections as part of responsible news consumption.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is The Guardian a reliable source?

According to multiple independent ratings and industry awards, theguardian.com is generally regarded as reliable. It is transparent about corrections, has won major industry awards, and is independently funded by the Scott Trust.

What is The Guardian’s political bias?

Media Bias/Fact Check and Ad Fontes Media rate The Guardian as “center-left.” It publishes a mix of news, analysis, and opinion.

Does The Guardian publish corrections?

Yes, The Guardian publishes regular corrections and maintains a transparent editorial complaints process.

Who owns The Guardian?

The Guardian is owned by the Scott Trust, which was established to safeguard its editorial independence.

How does The Guardian make money?

The Guardian is funded through reader contributions, digital subscriptions, and some advertising. Profits are reinvested in journalism.

How trustworthy is The Guardian compared to other UK newspapers?

Surveys such as the Reuters Digital News Report have ranked The Guardian among the most trusted UK newspapers among its regular readers.


Conclusion

theguardian.com is a major source of English-language news with a distinctive ownership structure, transparent editorial practices, and a record of awards and peer recognition. Independent ratings and fact-checking show that, while errors have occurred, these are generally acknowledged and addressed. In a complex media environment, The Guardian offers readers a high level of reliability, supported by published editorial standards and an open corrections process.

We recommend that readers consult multiple reputable news sources and review available corrections, regardless of outlet.

Grade composition
The overall rating is made up of the following individual ratings from independent third parties:
Journalism Awards35 +
Journalism prizes are awards for excellent journalistic work in the period covered by the call for entries, which is usually one or two years. Sources receive one plus point for each journalistic award won that we track. We currently track up to three prestigious awards per country.
Media Bias/Fact Check10 +, 10 -
Media Bias/Fact Check (MBFC) is an American fact-checking website founded in 2015. It uses a 0-10 scale to rate sites on two areas: bias and factual accuracy. A source rated by MBFC with minimal bias gets 10 plus points. Maximum bias gets 10 minus points. The same principle applies to factual accuracy.
Ad Fontes Media11 +, 9 -
Ad Fontes Media, Inc. is a media watchdog organization based in Colorado that is best known for its Media Bias Chart, which ranks media sources based on political bias and reliability. We combine their ratings of individual articles and episodes to create a weighted average, with low-rated items increasingly weighted higher.
    Reliability (Weighted Average)
  • "Medium"
Studies7 +, 3 -
Most scientific publications, though not all, rely on some form of peer review or editorial review to qualify texts for publication. Sources mentioned in studies which rate media quality and/or reliability receive between 10 plus and 10 minus points.
Wikipedia6 +, 2 -
Wikipedia’s reliability was frequently criticized in the 2000s. However, various studies and media reports have noted improvements over time, and in the late 2010s and early 2020s, it was more often praised. In the scoring model, any positive mention of a source’s credibility or quality in a Wikipedia extract receives a plus point—while negative mentions are treated as minus points.
Press Council Rulings
Press councils are national institutions of media self-regulation. Press councils have their own defined press code. Reprimands are issued in the event of a violation of the press code (e.g. for truthfulness, diligence, sensationalism, separation of advertising and editorial, personal rights). For each reprimand issued by a national press council, a source receives one minus point.
  • We are not aware of any press council rulings against this source to date.
Are these sources reliable?
Profile picture of BBC
BBC
@bbc.com
Profile picture of Reuters
Reuters
@reuters.com
Profile picture of The Economist
The Economist
@economist.com
Profile picture of CNN
CNN
@cnn.com
Profile picture of Channel 4
Channel 4
@channel4.com
Profile picture of washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
@washingtonpost.com
Profile picture of wsj.com
wsj.com
@wsj.com
Profile picture of The World from PRX
The World from PRX
@theworld.org
Profile picture of dw.com
dw.com
@dw.com
Profile picture of Metro.co.uk
Metro.co.uk
@metro.co.uk
News from reputable sources that might interest you
With Latest Epstein Emails, Democrats Dropped a Perfectly Timed Political Bomb: The bombshell emails come at a moment of peril for Republicans ...
time.com/7333256/epstein-emails-trump-takeaways/
With Latest Epstein Emails, Democrats Dropped a Perfectly Timed Political ...
Key FactsEpstein Emails Raise Questions About Trump’s Knowledge
3 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: zdfheute.de
  • Democrats released emails dated after Epstein’s 2008 conviction, sourced from his estate and submitted to a House committee.

  • The correspondence hints that Trump was aware of Epstein's activities, though no evidence confirms illegal conduct by Trump.

  • The White House calls the email leaks a politically motivated effort to damage Trump’s reputation.

  • Bipartisan support in Congress is building to compel the Justice Department to release all Epstein investigation files.
  • I want you to understand that the dog that doesn’t bark is Trump.
    Jeffrey Epstein to Ghislaine Maxwell in an email from April 2011.
Judge rules mandatory detention of Chicago day care teacher by ICE is illegal
chicagotribune.com/2025/11/12/federal-judge-illegal-ice-arrest-day-care-teacher/
Judge rules mandatory detention of Chicago day care teacher by ICE is ...
Key FactsMasked ICE Officers: Protection Amid Rising Tensions
2 days ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: theatlantic.com
  • ICE officers started wearing masks during raids under President Trump to conceal their identities from threats and harassment.

  • The masks have become a symbol of the intensified mass-deportation campaign and have drawn criticism for evoking secret police imagery.

  • Though optional, many agents consider face coverings essential for safeguarding themselves and their families from assaults and doxxing.

  • Legislators and the public demand clearer identification of officers, but removing masks entirely appears unlikely in the current climate.
  • People tend to be worse when they can be or think they are anonymous.
    — An ICE official described the effects of masking on police work.
MOMENTS AGO: Speaker Mike Johnson swears in Adelita Grijalva on the House floor
Key FactsAdelita Grijalva Sworn In After Prolonged Standoff
13 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: nbcnews.com
  • Adelita Grijalva was sworn into Congress more than seven weeks after her special election victory, concluding a prolonged dispute.

  • House Speaker Mike Johnson had delayed her swearing-in during the record-long government shutdown.

  • Her induction reduces the Republican majority in the House to 219-214, making it vulnerable to defections.

  • Grijalva immediately signed a bipartisan petition to compel the release of Justice Department files on Jeffrey Epstein.
  • This is an abuse of power. One individual should not be able to unilaterally obstruct the swearing in of a duly elected member of Congress for political reasons.
    Adelita Grijalva, during her speech after being sworn in in Congress, addressing the delay of her swearing in.
Key FactsThailand-Cambodia Border Violence Undermines 2025 Peace Deal
2 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: cnn.com
  • The peace agreement brokered by US President Trump is collapsing following deadly gunfire along the Thailand-Cambodia border.

  • Thailand suspended the accord after a landmine explosion injured four soldiers and accused Cambodia of laying new mines.

  • Cambodia reported attacks on civilians and demanded an independent probe into the border incident.

  • Both nations claim ownership of the contested border village, which has been a repeated flashpoint for violence and protests.
  • I call on the Thai side to immediately cease the use of force against innocent Cambodian civilians.
    Hun Manet, the Prime Minister of Cambodia, stated in a Facebook post regarding the recent border clashes.
Artist who created Chicago’s ‘Bean’ sculpture laments his work being used in CBP photos: ‘I find it utterly horrific’
independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/chicago-bean-artist-cbp-agents-photos-b2863888.html
Artist who created Chicago’s ‘Bean’ sculpture laments his work being used ...
Israeli crowd applauds soldiers accused of raping Palestinian prisoner: Two Israeli soldiers accused of raping a Palestinian detainee were met with cheers as ...
middleeasteye.net/news/israelis-applaud-soldiers-accused-raping-palestinian-prisoner-court-hearing
Israeli crowd applauds soldiers accused of raping Palestinian prisoner
Key FactsCheers for Soldiers Amid Rape Allegations in Court
20 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: middleeasteye.net
  • Two of five Israeli soldiers facing charges received applause from supporters identifying with their military unit, Unit 100.

  • The court hearing focused on who should lead the probe into leaked footage showing abuse of a Palestinian detainee.

  • The assault occurred in July 2024 at the Sde Teiman detention camp, resulting in severe injuries to the victim.

  • Disputes arose between the Justice Minister and Attorney General regarding control over the investigation into the video leak.
  • The injustice done to us is obvious to the people of Israel.
    — A guard speaking to the Israeli news outlet Channel 7.
“I Lost Everything”: Venezuelans Were Rounded Up in a Dramatic Midnight Raid but Never Charged With a Crime
propublica.org/article/chicago-venezuela-immigration-ice-fbi-raids-no-criminal-charges
“I Lost Everything”: Venezuelans Were Rounded Up in a Dramatic Midnight ...
‘Crazy’ JD Vance Calls Common Pain Medication ‘Useless’: “It’s not anti-medication, it’s anti-useless-medication,” the vice president tried to argue.
thedailybeast.com/crazy-jd-vance-calls-common-pain-medication-ibuprofen-useless-while-cozying-up-to-maha/
‘Crazy’ JD Vance Calls Common Pain Medication ‘Useless’
Jimmy Kimmel pays heartbreaking tribute to his best friend and band leader Cleto Escobedo III
mashable.com/video/jimmy-kimmel-tribute-cleto-escobedo-iii
Jimmy Kimmel pays heartbreaking tribute to his best friend and band leader ...
Key FactsJimmy Kimmel Honors Lifelong Friend and Band Leader
21 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: mashable.com
  • Jimmy Kimmel announced the passing of Cleto Escobedo III at age 59.

  • Escobedo led the band on Jimmy Kimmel Live! since its inception in 2003.

  • Their friendship began in childhood after Kimmel’s family moved to Las Vegas.

  • Kimmel highlighted the importance of valuing friendships due to life’s finite nature.
  • I'm heartbroken to lose him. I'm going to take yet another lesson from him and acknowledge how lucky I was to have him literally at my side for so many years.
    Jimmy Kimmel reflects on the loss of his best friend and band leader Cleto Escobedo III.
Magistrate judge, assistant US attorney, 5 plaintiff attorneys scheduled to tour Broadview facility Thursday, 11/13
chicagotribune.com/2025/11/12/broadview-site-visit-tro-extension/
Magistrate judge, assistant US attorney, 5 plaintiff attorneys scheduled ...
Protest in opposition of DeSantis as summit speaker : A group of about ten protesters gathered outside the Hamilton Princess & Beach Club this morning to ...
royalgazette.com/general/news/article/20251112/protest-in-opposition-of-desantis-as-summit-speaker/
Protest in opposition of DeSantis as summit speaker
Shutdown ends: Trump signs transitional budget: At 43 days, it was the longest shutdown in US history. Following an agreement in both houses of Congress ...
zdfheute.de/politik/ausland/usa-shutdown-abstimmung-haushalt-100.html
Shutdown ends: Trump signs transitional budget
Key FactsUS Shutdown Nears Historic End Amid Political Struggle
21 hours ago · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: zdfheute.de
  • The Senate approved a temporary budget extension, including retroactive salary payments for federal employees.

  • The House of Representatives is currently reviewing the Senate's proposal, with Republican unity uncertain due to some dissenters.

  • Democrats insist on extending tax credits under Obamacare to avoid sharp health insurance premium increases.

  • Despite progress toward ending the shutdown, political tensions persist as parties clash over key policy demands.
  • Workers want leaders whose words mean something.
    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Democratic Representative, speaks about workers' expectations of leaders during the shutdown.
Israeli soldiers involved in the rape of a Palestinian detainee at the Sde Teiman detention camp in July 2024 were applauded as they appeared in court on ... Show more