Black-red crisis over election of judges: Shortly before the vote, Spahn pulls the ripcord
spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/richterwahl-wie-union-und-spd-in-eine-schwere-krise-schlitterten-spiegel-rekonstruktion-a-3975a452-e027-4d9e-88a2-82ece4259638
Photo: spiegel.de · view article
Coalition Crisis Deepens Over Constitutional Judge VoteOn July 11, 2025, the vote for three constitutional judges collapsed amid internal opposition and allegations, straining SPD-CDU/CSU trust.
Key FactsJul 11, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: spiegel.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: spiegel.de
- The scheduled election of three constitutional judges was abruptly halted due to significant resistance within the CDU/CSU faction.
- SPD nominee Brosius-Gersdorf faced strong opposition from Union members, fueled by plagiarism allegations and ideological disputes.
- Despite attempts by faction leader Jens Spahn to rally support, many Union MPs refused to back Brosius-Gersdorf, resulting in the postponement of all judicial votes.
- This breakdown severely damaged coalition trust and raised concerns about the alliance’s future cooperation and stability.
You bear the responsibility primarily, Jens Spahn, and you, Mr. Merz!— Green party faction leader Britta Haßelmann refers to a 'disaster for Parliament', a bad day for democracy and the Constitutional Court.
Story Details
| Last Updated | |
| Total Articles | 2 |
Main Topics
centre-left political party in Germany
centre-right political party in Germany
Similar to This
Previous
“Worried that my reputation will suffer”: Judge candidate Brosius-Gersdorf still struggles with her withdrawal
n-tv.de/politik/Richterkandidatin-Brosius-Gersdorf-hadert-noch-immer-mit-ihrem-Rueckzug-article26069736.html
Federal Constitutional Court: Election committee recommends Emmenegger as SPD candidate
handelsblatt.com/politik/deutschland/bundesverfassungsgericht-wahlausschuss-empfiehlt-emmenegger-als-spd-kandidatin/100157026.html
Jens Spahn and Matthias Miersch: It couldn't be more different: Whether the coalition can govern successfully in the future depends on the leaders of the CDU/CSU ...
taz.de/Jens-Spahn-und-Matthias-Miersch/!6106034/
Union faction leader: Spahn wants to strengthen cohesion in the coalition through team building
zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2025-08/jens-spahn-schwarz-rot-koalition-teambuilding
Internal criticism after judge selection debacle: CDU member of parliament makes accusations against Spahn
fr.de/politik/verfassungsrichterwahl-debakel-uebergeht-spahn-seine-fraktion-zr-93878169.html
Key FactsCDU Demands Clear Guidelines After Failed Judge Election
Aug 11, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: berliner-zeitung.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: berliner-zeitung.de
- The CDU rejected SPD candidate Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf, causing the judge election to fail.
- Saskia Ludwig reproaches faction leader Jens Spahn for not consulting the CDU before talks with the SPD.
- Ludwig calls for mandatory minimum standards and transparent candidate presentations ahead of future appointments.
- The Brosius-Gersdorf controversy has intensified internal disputes and criticism of Ludwig’s own background.
A significant part of your CDU/CSU parliamentary group had elected you as their group leader with 91.3 percent just two months prior and found Ms. Brosius-Gersdorf unacceptable.— Saskia Ludwig criticizes Jens Spahn in her letter regarding the judge election.
“If the SPD is always the fool” - Coalition falters due to scandal surrounding Brosius-Gersdorf
hna.de/politik/wenn-die-spd-immer-der-depp-ist-koalition-wankt-wegen-eklat-um-brosius-gersdorf-zr-93874473.html
Key FactsCoalition Faces Turmoil Over Judicial Appointment
Aug 10, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: hna.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: hna.de
- The nomination of Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf as a constitutional judge sparked a major crisis in the coalition government.
- SPD members reproach the Union for lacking coalition discipline and foresee challenges in future cooperation.
- Right-wing media attacks on Brosius-Gersdorf's liberal views caused division within the Union party.
- Youth wing leaders demand accountability from CDU officials and criticize right-wing influence within the Union.
If the SPD is always the fool, the coalition cannot function. Such a thing must not happen again, otherwise the coalition is over.— Jens Peick, Dortmund SPD member of the Bundestag, comments on the current crisis in the coalition.
Election of judges: Summer of mistrust: The coalition between the CDU/CSU and SPD enters the summer break disgruntled and divided. A solution to the election of ...
zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2025-07/richterwahl-streit-bundesregierung-spd-cdu-sommerpause
CDU General Secretary Linnemann announces "autumn of reforms" in the welfare state
stern.de/news/cdu-generalsekretaer-linnemann-kuendigt--herbst-der-reformen--im-sozialstaat-an-35909968.html
Key FactsCoalition Seeks Quiet Resolution to Court Appointment Dispute
Jul 21, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: zeit.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: zeit.de
- Carsten Linnemann believes the controversy around Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf has not caused permanent harm to the governing coalition.
- Opposition to Brosius-Gersdorf stems from church officials, legal experts, and medical ethicists, with internal church disagreements evident.
- Accusations that Jens Spahn aims to deliberately destabilize the coalition are strongly denied by Linnemann.
- The Left party demands a revised nomination process for constitutional judges and refuses a special parliamentary session until Union and SPD resolve their conflict.
That is a perfidious allegation, and I am quite sure that Ms. Lang knows that as well.— Carsten Linnemann comments on the accusations against Jens Spahn in the Tagesspiegel.
Haßelmann teases CDU man about Spahn preparation - | and gives his own answer: After the judge election debacle, CDU politician Christoph Ploß tried to defend ...
focus.de/politik/deutschland/hasselmann-triezt-cdu-mann-mit-spahn-vorbereitung-und-gibt-antwort-selbst_8a89b959-4d27-47ee-baa7-237a4208ac43.html
Constitutional judge election: Miersch outraged by Bishop's statement: SPD parliamentary group leader Miersch has rejected statements made by Bamberg Archbishop ...
zdfheute.de/politik/deutschland/richterwahl-verfassungsgericht-kritik-spd-miersch-bischof-100.html
Key FactsDebate Erupts Over Brosius-Gersdorf’s Court Nomination
Jul 14, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: welt.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: welt.de
- The SPD continues to support Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf despite controversies surrounding her views on abortion laws.
- Bishop Herwig Gössl criticized her nomination as a political scandal reflecting declining moral responsibility.
- SPD leader Matthias Miersch condemned church leaders’ involvement as an unchristian campaign against the nominee.
- The Bamberg diocese highlighted the importance of unborn life protection and called for constructive ethical discussions.
To participate in this hatred is un-Christian.— SPD parliamentary leader Matthias Miersch, regarding the criticism of Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf.
After dispute with judge: Federal President Steinmeier considers black-red coalition “damaged”
tagesspiegel.de/politik/nach-richterstreit-steinmeier-halt-schwarz-rote-koalition-fur-beschadigt-14016605.html
Key FactsCoalition Faces Strain After Judge Appointment Dispute
Jul 13, 2025 · Reading time: ~45 sec.
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: spiegel.de
Summary created with AI assistance · Source: spiegel.de
- President Steinmeier criticized the black-red coalition for damaging itself after postponing the constitutional judges' election.
- The Union unexpectedly opposed SPD nominee Frauke Brosius-Gersdorf due to allegations of plagiarism and liberal abortion views.
- Steinmeier emphasized the urgency of a decision to protect the authority and function of the Federal Constitutional Court.
- The Bundestag’s next regular session is scheduled for September 10, by which time a solution should be reached.
I believe that if you take a look at the newspapers from the weekend, you will immediately learn that the coalition has certainly damaged itself.— Federal President Frank-Walter Steinmeier stated this in the 'Summer Interview' on ZDF, regarding the postponed election of the constitutional judges.
Spahn admits his joint responsibility for the first time: "Nothing to gloss over": Three days after the memorable failure of the judges' election ...
tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/spahn-richterwahl-100.html
Federal government: SPD politicians question the reliability of the CDU/CSU: The debate about the failed election of the candidate for the Federal Constitutional ...
handelsblatt.com/politik/deutschland/bundesregierung-spd-politiker-stellen-verlaesslichkeit-der-union-infrage/100141230.html
Dispute over choice of judge: Spahn and Merz in a tight spot: At the start of the summer break, of all times, a coalition crisis is looming due to the dispute ...
t-online.de/nachrichten/tagesanbruch/id_100814928/streit-ueber-richterwahl-spahn-und-merz-stecken-in-der-klemme.html
CDU/CSU wants to postpone the election of a female judge candidate: There may be a last-minute change in the Bundestag regarding the election of a judge to the ...
zdfheute.de/politik/deutschland/bundesverfassungsgericht-wahl-bundestag-verschiebung-100.html
Bundestag: How the election of judges plunged the coalition into its first crisis
handelsblatt.com/politik/deutschland/bundestag-wie-die-richterwahl-die-koalition-in-ihre-erste-krise-stuerzt/100141043.html
Election of judges in the Bundestag: Lars Klingbeil calls for "leadership and responsibility" from the CDU/CSU
zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2025-07/lars-klingbeil-richterwahl-grosse-koalition-verantwortung
Wave of outrage - Merz and Spahn pull the ripcord on judge election: A wave of outrage has swept the CDU/CSU because they wanted to elect the controversial SPD ...
rp-online.de/politik/deutschland/merz-und-spahn-ziehen-bei-richterwahl-von-umstrittener-kandidatin-reissleine_aid-130933637
Burst election of judges shakes coalition: Chancellor Merz wanted a coalition without public disputes - unlike the traffic lights. A good two months after taking ...
ga.de/news/politik/deutschland/geplatzte-richterwahl-erschuettert-koalition_aid-130923901
Delicate judge election: What could happen in the Bundestag today: After long discussions, the time has come today: The Bundestag will decide on the new ...
noz.de/deutschland-welt/politik/artikel/heikle-richterwahl-was-heute-im-bundestag-passieren-kann-48972200
Paid articlePaywall Next